Monday, 27 May 2024

A Critical Analysis of “The Strange Affair of Robin. S Ngangnom”

(Robin S. Ngangnom)

The Poem:

Not once can I say

I am the captain

behind this wheel of fire.

I remember misplacing

a bronze bell

somewhere, sometime.

I left behind many untended hearths.

Rushing back I discovered

something had changed me.

I can say

I am this or that,

that I envied the character

of water and stone.

that I envied the character

of water and stone.

As a boy I was made a sheep,

now I am enchanted into a goat

that the townspeople

enjoy driving to the square

with a marigold garland

between my hornş.

At twenty-four

I invited myself to Bohemia.

The kingdom of Art,

where people never grow old,

was my affable neighbour.

Moved by curiosity,

I found myself lingering

at backstages, where painted girls

and poor blind boys

came to do their parts.

In the evenings now,

I often mix my drink with despair.

Love, of course, made me entirely useless.

This is the story of my people.

We sowed suspicion in the fields.

Hatred sprang and razed the crops.

Now they go to gloating (glorying) neighbours,

begging bowls in hand,

fingers pointed at each other.

Their incessant bickering (backbiting)

Muffles (quiets) all pity.

Our intentions are clear.

Slash (Tear) and burn,

let fire erase all traces,

so that suspicion cannot write

our murderous history.

Somewhere inside the labyrinth

we met, locked horns, and

went our feuding ways.

Our past, we believe, is pristine

even as we reaped heads and took slaves.

When we re-write make-believę history

with malicious intent,

memory burns on a short fuse.

As boys return to Christmas,

escorted by hate and fear,

they take a circuitous route

to outwit an enemy

who will revel too much in the birth

of a merciful son. When these boys

reach home, their dreams will come

dressed in red.

II

Hands filled with love,

I touched your healing breasts.

Like the beaten-up past

scars appeared on your body.

I ask, who branded the moonskin of my love?

Who used you like a toy doll?

And my hands returned to me

stigmatised with guilt.

When I turn with a heavy heart

towards my flaming country,

the hills, woman, scream your name.

Soldiers with black sçarves (mufflers)

like mime artists

turn them in seconds into shrouds.

For the trucks carrying

the appliances of death and devastation,

for the eager rescuer in his armoured car,

for the first visitor to the fabled homeland,

the graves of youths who died in turmoil

are the only milestones to the city.

But the hills lie draped (dressed) in mist.

Instead of the musk of your being

I inhale the acrid smoke

of gelignite (explosive) and pyres.

With cargoes of sand and mortar

Mammon came to inspect the city.

He cut down the remaining trees

and carried them away

like cadavers (corpses) for dissection.

Morning papers like watered-down milk

sell the same bland items:

rape, extortion, ambushes (traps), confessions,

embezzlement, vendetta (campaign), sales,

marriages, the usual.

There is talk on the streets,

in dark comers, in homes, words

caught by the ears of a restaurant.

We honour the unvarying certainty,

and pay routine homage to silence.

Everyone has correctly identified

the enemy of the people.

He wears a new face each morning,

and freedom is asking yourself

if you are free, day after sullen (morose) day.

III

Uprightness is not caressing (touching) anything publicly,

Integrity is not drinking,

Worthiness is contributing generously to a new faith

to buy guns for unleashing (set free) ideological horror,

Service is milking the state

and when you can lift no more

to start burgling each other

so that we can become paragons of thievery,

Chastity is forbidding our women

from exposing their legs,

Purity is not whispering

even a solitary word of love

so that it will not be mistaken

for unpardonable obscenity.

Nothing is certain:

oil

lentils

potatoes

food for babies

transport

the outside world.

Even fire water and air

are slowly becoming commodities.

Patriotism is the need of the hour.

Patriotism is preaching secession

and mourning our merger with a nation,

patriotism is honouring martyrs

who died in confusion,

patriotism is declaring we should

preserve native customs and traditions,

our literature and performing arts,

and inflicting them on hapless peoples,

patriotism is admiring

the youth who fondles grenades,

patriotism is proclaiming all men are brothers

and secretly depriving my brother,

patriotism is playing the music of guns

to the child in the womb.

Stones speak, the hills speak

when we finally fall silent.

History, hunch-backed friend,

why do we fear you,

why do we love, hate, lie,

conceal, merely to enact you

in the coarse theatre of time?

IV

Today, I stand alone and acknowledge

the left-handed gift of a man

without a woman, and

a tiny land bound by fire.

Slave to an unexamined life

all that I’ve done

I’ve accomplished blindfolded:

love, fear, anger, and old despair.

The penitent (repentant) year wears sackcloth

and pours ashen leaves on its head,

the sky’s dress is in shreds.

When stars appear, they hold up the sky

like nuts and bolts so that

the firmament will not fall.

But we who sleep under these stars

will not let each other dream.

Love is also a forgotten word.

The ability to suffer, and the ability

to inflict the utmost hurt

on the person you love most,

this is how I’ve known it.

The festival of lights

happened during childhood.

Today, I’m again with widows

who cannot light lamps anymore.

Maybe the land is tired.

of being suckled on blood,

maybe there is no peace

between the farmer and his fields,

maybe all men everywhere

are tired of being men,

maybe we have finally acknowledged death.

My love, how can I explain

that I abominate (hate) laws

When I am gone

I would leave you these:

a life without mirrors, and

the blue ode between pines

between pines and the winter sky.

But where can one run from the homeland,

where can I flee from your love?

They have become pursuing prisons

which hold the man

with criminal words.


Introduction

Written in the year 1959, with a purpose to showcase the environment of Manipur when it first became part of the Indian Union, “The Strange Affair of Robin. S Ngangnom”, is a vivid portrayal of the horrors that Manipur succumbed to during that period.

It is a highly politically charged poem which puts profound focus on the gruesome and atrocious change which filled this pristine land with hunger, death and destruction. Ngangom describes his poetry as “mostly autobiographical, written with the hope of enthusing readers with my communal or carnal life — the life of a politically-discriminated-against, historically-overlooked individual from the nook of a third world country”.

Analysis

The poem starts with the poet excluding himself from the “wheel of fire” which suggests the destruction and violence around him which he cannot control. He does not want to be part of it but is forced to be a witness to such horrors because he has nowhere else to go. The next few lines are the poet reminiscing about his past, his childhood. He talks about how he remembers “misplacing a bronze bell somewhere, sometime” and how “I left behind many untended hearths”, suggesting that he lost his cultural identity and due to the changes, which Manipur passed through, that land lost its traditional values as well.

The scope of the poem shifts from the personal to include the plight and suffering of his land at large, “This is the story of my people”. Gradually the poem traces the entire bloody history of Manipur and the sufferings the people of the land had to go through leading it to the present state of degeneration. Ngangnom mentions how the people of Manipur have become selfish which ultimately became the cause of more hatred in the already doomed land, “Now they go to gloating neighbours, begging bowls in hand,”. The poet goes on to point out that no matter how many times the past is re-written, no matter how many fictitious provocations are added in the “make- believe history”, the truth will always prevail.

He talks about the youths returning home for Christmas but they are met with hate and fear. They take long, indirect routes to outsmart their enemies who would be happy in “the birth of a merciful son.” He refers to how the women always faced the worst consequences in the form of sexual assaults and rapes, “I touched your healing breasts. Like the beaten-up past scars appeared on your body.” He draws attention to the conflict between the Indian Army and insurgents in the land.

Therefore, Ngangom turns to his land with a heavy heart to describe the suffering that the land is bearing. “When I turn with a heavy heart towards my flaming country, the hills, woman, scream your name.” This is also a reference to The Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA) permits the armed forces the authority to shoot anyone on the basis of mere suspicion which often resulted in mass killing of innocents/peaceful protestors. “But the hills lie draped in mist. Instead of the musk of your being I inhale the acrid smoke of gelignite and pyres.”

There came a period when capitalism started to rise and the violence against humanity became so common that it started to sound “bland”. “He cut down the remaining trees and carried them away like cadavers for dissection. Morning papers like watered-down milk sell the same bland items: rape, extortion, ambushes, confessions, embezzlement, vendetta, sales, marriages, the usual.” The poet points out that the words like patriotism and uprightness have lost their values. He talks about patriotism is mourning the merging of Manipur with India and honoring those souls who died in midst of chaos. To him, patriotism is declaring that their native customs and traditions, literature, and performing arts should be preserved. “Patriotism is proclaiming all men are brothers”, nevertheless, his brothers have been deprived. Patriotism is playing the chattering of guns to the child who is sleeping in the womb. The brutality of the violence has taken such stern courses that people have forgotten basic emotions which define their humanity. “But we who sleep under these stars will not let each other dream. Love is also a forgotten word.”

But even though the land is covered with such destruction and ghastliness, the poet can still not decline his motherland. He is depressed to think about the state of his land and how it has become “tired” now and can no longer tolerate the hideousness of violence. He is in despair while writing this poem, calling the land “My love”because he also knows no matter how far- away he runs he can never deny his love for his birthplace and can never run away from his roots.

Conclusion

“The Strange affair of Robin. S Ngangnom”, points out the awful situation that surrounded Manipur and attempts to presents the outcry of helpless people of the land. The poet has become tired of the events which are taking place in the land.

Therefore, Robin S. Ngangom, through his poem “The Strange Affairs of Robin S.Ngangom” is hopeful about the peace in his land.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Ibsen's idea of Realism and its contribution to Modern European Drama.

  Born in the small town of Norway, called Skien in 1828, Henrik Ibsen is known as one of the most influential pioneers of Realism. He is sa...