Wednesday, 8 May 2024

A critical analysis of Disney’s “Mulan” (1998)

 
“The flower that blooms in adversity is the most rare and beautiful of all.” 

Mulan (1998), is an animated Disney Princess movie and is arguably known as one of the greatest as well as the most compelling narrative from a Disney product. The story blends elements of folklore, adventure, supernatural and empowerment and the movie is celebrated for its portrayal of Chinese culture. But at its core, “Mulan” is a story of defying gender norms and female empowerment. The titular character is the classic “I’m not like other girls” character, but this movie is one of those rare narratives where one can see this trope from a positive lens.




“Mulan” follows the story of Fa Mulan, a young maiden living in ancient China during the Han dynasty. She is somebody who is not really good at anything, whether it is the stereotypical “manly” things like working out, being physically strong or the stereotypical feminine things like “the right way to make tea, apply makeup and dressing up.” The lack of these latter traits was what gets her described as a failure in the eyes of the local matchmaker and the society. When the Huns, led by the villainous and ruthless Shan Yu, invade China, the Emperor issues a decree conscripting one man from every family to join the army. As there were no sons in the Fa family, it is Mulan’s father, Fa Zhou, who is conscripted to go to war against the Huns.
Unfortunately, he was too old and frail to fight. To save her father from lifelong injuries and possible death, Mulan, cuts her hair with her father’s sword, dons on her father’s armour and disguising herself as a man, she secretly goes in his place. With her unusual side-kicks, that being a little spirit dragon, Mushu as well as a lucky cricket called Cri- Kee, she, under the alias “Ping”, goes under rigorous training along with her fellow soldiers, led by the stern but honorable Captain Li Shang. Mulan faces several challenges as she navigates the male- dominated world of the military. In comparison to her comrades, she struggles to keep up and is often chastised by Shang for her perceived incompetence.

However, despite initial struggles, Mulan, gradually proves herself to be a skilled and courageous warrior who is worthy to fight in the war. In the meanwhile, the Huns continue to advance and the Chinese army prepare for battle. To her dismay, Mulan’s true identity is revealed when she gets injured during a training exercise. Despite her lie and deception, Shang spares her life but expels her from the army. When Mulan was gathering herself from her melancholic situation in the middle of the snowy mountains, where she was left, she learns that Shan Yu along with his army is on its way to the Imperial city and plans to assassinate the emperor. Realizing that she must stop them, Mulan devises a plan to warn the emperor which should eventually result in saving China. With the help of her friends from the army, including the comedic trio of Yao, Ling, and Chien-Po, Mulan infiltrates the city and confronts Shan Yu. 

Her training and presence of mind comes in handy when Mulan, with her intelligence and resourcefulness, outsmarts Shan Yu and ultimately defeats him, saving the emperor and China. When the fight settles down and she is summoned in front of the emperor and the people, Mulan gets recognized for her bravery and sacrifice and is offered a place in the emperor’s court by the emperor himself. In the end, Mulan's actions not only bring honor to her family but makes her China’s greatest heroines in the process. She also challenges the rigid gender roles of her society, proving that a woman can be as capable and heroic as any man. 

Somewhere in the midst of the chaos that unravels in the story, the audience sees Mulan doubting herself and questioning her actions. But she abides by the conclusion that she cannot back off now when so much was at stake and she knew that her real identity and her actions will bring great dishonor to her family and father, which was worse than death for him. This firmness in character, stern decisions and possessing the strength of the soul is what turned Mulan from being a clumsy and meek woman to an honorable warrior and makes “Mulan” a beautiful & a great coming-of-age movie. 
“Mulan" explores themes of gender identity and societal expectations. Set in the time and society when women were looked down upon and sometimes even punished just for speaking out of turn, Mulan defies traditional gender norms, challenging the notion that women are incapable of being warriors. The movie also sticks out in the minds of the audience for several other reasons. 

For once, it provides the audience with a strong female lead, at least stronger than most of the other Disney princesses even though she is not really counted among the Disney “princesses” line-up. The movie resonates with the audience, especially young girls, for its empowering themes and encourages them to not abide by the limitations imposed by the society. When one sees Mulan make the decision to join the army in her father’s place, she does so out of love for him, valuing his life over hers.
While "Mulan" celebrates Mulan's defiance of patriarchal expectations, it also critiques the oppressive nature of gender roles for not just women but for men as well. It was only the men who were expected to fight and die in the war leaving no choice for the ones who didn’t want to. This lack of choice towards both the genders is the reason why Mulan was compelled to do what she did. 

In conclusion, "Mulan" offers a complex portrayal of gender dynamics, empowerment, and cultural representation. It challenges traditional gender norms and celebrates female empowerment, resonating with the audience across the world and inviting rich material for feminist analysis and discussion.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Ibsen's idea of Realism and its contribution to Modern European Drama.

  Born in the small town of Norway, called Skien in 1828, Henrik Ibsen is known as one of the most influential pioneers of Realism. He is sa...